« Remember Antitrust? Microsoft does! | Main | My latest (and long-overdue) MSNBC.COM column: Microsoft vs. Google »

Libraries are for everyone

Jack Stephens, a conservative librarian writing on his blogConservator, responds appropriately to a very troubling essay floating around the Internets:

JUST TAKE THE TITLE of this week's much-discussed essay on the homeless in America's public libraries as it appeared at the self-described "progressive echo chamber," AlterNet:

"America Gone Wrong: A Slashed Safety Net Turns Libraries into Homeless Shelters"

Paternalistic and crassly exploitative enough for you?

The presence of poor people in America's public libraries is a problem, which means they are fair game to be used to score political points about "America Gone Wrong."

Not paternalistic and exploitative enough? Consider the concluding passage of the introduction for the piece as it appeared at the Nation Institute's Tom Dispatch site:

[P]ublic libraries have become de facto daytime shelters for the nation's street people; while librarians are increasingly our unofficial social workers for the homeless (and often the disturbed). It's a dirty little secret that tells us all too much about the state of our nation today.

"Street people," whose presence in America's public libraries is a "dirty little secret." At least they're still good for some pungent negative commentary about America.

Getting beyond the progressive title and introduction, author Chip Ward piques his readers' indignation:

Scenes from a psych ward? Not at all. Welcome to the Salt Lake City Public Library.

"Psych ward." How wonderfully enlightened.

Mr. Ward himself gives the starting signal for the political point-scoring at the expense of library patrons:

When the mentally ill whom we have thrown onto the streets haunt our [!] public places, their presence tells us something important about the state of our union, our national character, our priorities, and our capacity to care for one another.

Paternalistic and exploitative enough?

The indigent people who "haunt" my library in downtown Los Angeles sit in chairs and read books and magazines, or surf the Web, much like anyone else. Occasionally, they come up to the reference desk to ask for assistance.

Right on, Jack (no pun intended)! I had the same reactions when I read that essay.

Comments

I never cease to be impressed by some people's lack of charity. Here in the Houston area, my local public library (http://www.hcpl.net/branchinfo/fm/fminfo.htm) was an incredible resource for one group of homeless people, Katrina evacuess. I got to know quite a few evacuees there after the hurricane. The public library was their lifeline. It provided internet access, news, shelter and a great venue for rapport building and support between themselves and the local community. Public libraries are for the public and I am always glad to share the library with whoever needs it, no matter what their condition or state of mind.

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?