« Satirical Video About "Sexual Harassment in the Workplace" | Main | How did I miss this?: 2 Live Crew's 'Pretty Woman' in a video mashup »

Apologies on behalf of all Longhorns: The Aggies are actually right this time

JJR, better known in the library blogosphere as the Aggie Librarian, points us to this story:

UT sues Aggie retailer over
'saw em off'
10:27 AM CST on Tuesday, January 23, 2007

Associated Press

COLLEGE STATION, Texas -- The University of Texas is countering a jab from an Aggie business owner by taking him to court over his “saw em off” variation of the familiar Longhorn logo.

'Saw em off' lawsuit

The UT System Board of Regents claims in its lawsuit that Fadi Kalaouze’s merchandise adorned with an inverted Longhorn logo with its horns detached is a trademark infringement.

The lawsuit argues that Kalaouze, a 1991 Texas A&M University graduate and the owner of two College Station stores, is illegally using a design that tarnishes and mutilates the trademarked Longhorn logo.

“This is not a dispute with Texas A&M. It is a dispute with a private company that is unfairly profiting from use of the UT logo and at the same time mutilating the logo,” said Craig Westemeirer, director of the University of Texas Office of Trademark Licensing.

Kalaouze contends that his emblem is a parody and is protected by the First Amendment. He said in court filings that the lawsuit is a “legally baseless display of poor sportsmanship.”

The lawsuit filed last month names Kalcorp, which is owned by Kalaouze and is the parent company for both of his stores. It seeks a permanent injunction to stop the company from selling the symbol, as well as attorneys fees, damages and the company’s profits from selling the emblem.

UT’s lawsuit says that the “saw em off” logo, which has been placed on merchandise such as T-shirts and bumper stickers, could confuse consumers because of its similarity to the Longhorn logo.

Kalaouze said nobody would mistake his emblem for the actual Longhorn logo, and he doesn’t believe any Longhorn supporters have accidentally purchased one of his shirts or stickers. He has established a Web site to raise money for his legal fight.

“We honestly don’t believe anyone is confusing this logo with their logo. We have been sawing their horns off for many years,” Kalaouze said. “We just want to make sure the tradition lives on.”

Westemeirer said the UT logo is “one of the most recognized brands in America” and must be protected.

“We want to present the logo as a consistent image to the public — that is not possible if others, such as the defendants, modify or mutilate the logo,” he said.

Mike Huddleston, Texas A&M’s vice president for business development, said Texas A&M would likely have taken similar action if it faced the same scenario as UT.

“I’m just surprised it took them so long,” Huddleston said.

How shameful of my Alma Mater! Even though the University of Texas is indisputably the finest institution of higher learning on the planet and was until a few weeks ago the reigning National Champions in football, it should never have stooped this low.

First, Mr. Kalaouze and all of us MUST be free to ridicule trademarks and symbols. Such depictions are essential in a free society. The University of Texas has no business trying to stomp out every critic who deploys an altered image of the university's symbols. Besides, the University of Texas and all of its symbols belong to all Texans, even the Aggies who don't appreciate excellence as much as the rest of us do.

Second, Mr. Kalaouze is clearly adapting to a sad fact about his potential market: many of them are not so good with the book larnin'. So he has to use cartoon images instead of words to render his ideas in understandable form. Images are an important part of language and deserve the same free speech protections as other forms of communication. Mr. Kalaouze is just serving his Aggie customers.

Third, since when does UT care if someone "tarnishes" a bovine head? Don't we have better things to worry about? We are trying to solve all the world's problems. Why be so petty? Is the University of Texas really so insecure and paranoid about criticism that it has to stomp on every poor Aggie who has a dumb idea for a t-shirt? Please. I think not.

So, if you are a proud Longhorn like me, please call or write to the UT System General Counsel's office to complain.

Hook'em!

Comments

if this case goes in favor of the univerity of Texas, is using a capital L when writing the word longhorn , when it is not the first word in a sentence or given the proper and legal citation, to be considered an infringement subject to the university's control? should one use the upper case of the letter when writing of breeds of cattle?

At least the use of the label "The University" is still protected.

I sincerely apologize for the bad spelling and not using a capital in the name. Is the stand alone phrase " The University " really a copyrighted name? Or is that only when followed by " of Texas "?

*sigh* I don't think so, but UT(tm) is.
http://www.utexas.edu/trademarks/marks.html

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?