« Is She Supposed To Represent a “Media Whore"? | Main | “All Iraq is Abu Ghraib” »

Nothing to Say about the Bombay bombings?

Sepia Mutiny writes:

While trying to deal with the tragedy in Mumbai, I have been wondering what the coverage of the story tells us about ourselves.

I was not surprised by MSM coverage in America: poor in local papers, better in papers with a large desi population or those with an international audience. I was pleased to hear that CNN and CNBC had decent cable news coverage, perhaps because they’re well established in India.

What has baffled me, however, is the relative silence from the world of blogs. The blogosphere is supposed to be the cutting edge, far more advanced than the MSM, yet they’re spending less time on the story.

Mutiny goes on to catalog the lack of response by major political blogs in the United States, both left and right. Of course, this blog does not rank up there with the Instapundits and Koses of the world. But we have failed to blog about the train bombings that slaughtered hundreds.

And, as Mutiny pointed out about so many other blogs, we wrote a lot about the London bombings last summer.

Here is my reason (excuse?): I don't have anything relevant to say about the Bombay bombings yet. No one knows who was behind them. No one knows the motivation. No one knows how to plays into domestic tensions, Kashmir, or India-Pakistan relations. No one knows if it's Maoist rebels or Islamic terrorists or some insane cult.

In the next couple of weeks we will know more. And we will see how it relates to other problems and conflicts in South Asia and the world at large. Then I might have something to say about it. If the bombing did involve Kashmiri insurgents, backed by the security service of Pakistan, then the United States would be implicated as well. The US has for decades given Pakistan a blank check to support nuclear proliferation and terrorism in the name of both radical Islam and general instability. But until we know that, we can't really indict anyone.

In the mean time, the horror is so profound and overwhelming that any words from me on this blog would seem cheap.

Comments

I thought of posting something, but I really didn't know what to say. I'm very glad you posted this. After the London bombings I particularly responded to this site: http://www.nyu.edu/classes/siva/archives/001621.html
I just returned from six weeks in Europe and rode trains almost every day. I'd ride them here too if we had any in Columbia SC. I am not afraid.

You say :

"In the next couple of weeks we will know more."

But you will still not cover it, since Mumbai does not involve european casualties, its not important to you guys. Someone even said on SepiaMutiny.com that majority of Americans dont consider events where non-whites are killed, as "terrorism". For them its brown on brown violence.

Please not that this is not a plea for sympathy. I am pointing out that due to your ethnocentric and eurocentric bias you are missing a major terroristic event involving Al Queda. Also it is important to study this because a millions of Americans use trains everyday and a Mumbai type event is possible here, as security on trains is way less than that on Airports.

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?